The Minnesota Twins have had a surprising start to the offseason that continued when Sonny Gray signed a two-year, $55 million contract with the team on Wednesday. The deal, which includes a player option for the 2028 season, has Gray returning to the city where he finished as the runner-up in Cy Young voting in 2023 and gives a significant lift to the starting rotation.
While Gray’s leadership and experience give the Twins the type of rotation depth they’ve struggled to find since he left as a free agent the following winter, it also leaves a massive question in the bullpen. But signing Gray could actually help the pen and follow the same blueprint that the Milwaukee Brewers used to win the World Series last season.
Minnesota Twins can follow Milwaukee Brewers’ blueprint to build a stronger bullpen in 2027
The Twins' bullpen was a big source of frustration among fans last season. While some teams paid big for relievers, Minnesota sat on its hands and opted for low-risk fliers to fill it out.
On paper, this is a solid strategy due to the year-to-year volatility of relievers. It even worked in the Twins’ favor in some cases, as they found a gem by converting pitching prospect Andrew Morris into a reliever and found another when they claimed Yoendrys Gomez on waivers last May.
But in the end, there were too many experiments that didn’t pan out. The Twins finished with the fifth-worst bullpen ERA in baseball at 4.74 and also allowed the sixth-worst batting average (.256) and third-worst WHIP (1.49).
Those numbers were a big reason why the Twins brought in Jeff Hoffman and A.J. Minter at the trade deadline. While the Twins still have Hoffman under team control for next season, Minter is a highly coveted free agent, and some believe it would be a wise move to sign him to a contract projected by FanGraphs at one year and $6 million.
But the evidence against that move comes from across the Mississippi River, where the Brewers used a dominant bullpen to bring home a championship.
The Brewers had some high-powered traditional relievers such as Abner Uribe and Trevor Megill. But they also accumulated starting pitching depth with the idea of using the leftover arms in the bullpen. DL Hall, Aaron Ashby and Dustin May were some of the former starters who came out of the pen during Milwaukee’s championship run and it helped lessen the load on their starters as each player could go multiple innings to carry a lead to the ninth inning.
This helped the Brewers bring home the Commissioner’s Trophy for the first time in franchise history and could explain why the Twins spent big to bring Gray back to Minnesota.
Twins starting rotation depth could become a major bullpen advantage
Looking at the Twins, they suddenly have a logjam of capable starters. Gray slots in toward the top of the rotation, but he’s also joined by Joe Ryan and Taj Bradley. The Twins will also get Pablo Lopez back from Tommy John surgery and have Dean Kremer under team control after acquiring him at last year’s trade deadline.
If all goes according to plan, the Twins should have their five starters set for next season. But they also have a second wave of talented arms.
Mick Abel had a strong spring training and showed some promise, pitching 13 straight scoreless innings and striking out 10 in his final start against the Boston Red Sox on April 14 before elbow problems shut him down for the year.
Zebby Matthews has also shown flashes at times as a starter. But his velocity and stuff could play up in the bullpen, similar to the way Louis Varland became a shutdown reliever after initially resisting the move earlier in his career.
Kendry Rojas and Connor Prielipp have also seen some success at the major league level and David Festa is another player who could return from injury next season.
In total, this gives the Twins 10 pitchers who are capable of starting games. Some of them will be needed as injuries occur throughout the season, but others could go to the bullpen, giving the Twins a variety of options that could make their bullpen better next season.
For a team that threw stuff at the wall one year ago, having several pitchers to build a bullpen internally beats not getting a proper investment of $10 million. With the added benefit of using the savings to invest in the lineup, the bullpen vision may become clear and the Twins may be holding the answer without overspending on a high-caliber reliever.
