MLB Rumors: Should Twins trade Sonny Gray at the deadline?

Sonny Gray might be the Twins best trade chip, but should Minnesota cash in at the deadline or continue holding?

Chicago White Sox v Minnesota Twins
Chicago White Sox v Minnesota Twins / Brace Hemmelgarn/GettyImages
2 of 2
Next

As the MLB Trade Deadline quickly approaches, the biggest question for the Minnesota Twins will be wether to be buyers or sellers.

This shouldn't really be up for debate, since the Twins are division leaders and in contention for the postseason. However, peel back the layers and the situation reveals itself to be a rather unique one in the that the AL Central is hardly a difficult division to win and Minnesota's lead is rather slim.

That's what makes the deadline decision to buy or sell so difficult, with Sonny Gray serving as perhaps the most unique variable of all.

Gray is having one of the best seasons of his career, something that has captured the attention of pitching-needy teams around the league. Starters are always a hot commodity this time of the year, and the Twins appear to have a golden ticket in Gray.

What to do with him at the deadline has sparked fierce debate, so let's break down both sides of the argument.

Yes, the Twins should trade Sonny Gray

This arguement basically comes down to whether the Twins want to seriously compete now or take one more swing at building a contender in the future.

Minnesota has been forever kicking the can down the road to make room for the next Big Move, but at a certain point that needs to stop. However, if there's a situation that perhaps warrants putting off the present to ensure a future, it might be flipping Gray for a haul at the deadline.

One motivating factor could be what happened at last year's deadline. The Twins dipped into the farm system to pull off two splashy trades that ultimately didn't work out. The aftermath is watching the Orioles and Reds thrive with guys like Spencer Steer and Yannier Cano while both Tyler Mahle and Jorge Lopez are no longer on the team (Mahle is still under contract but he's undergoing Tommy John surgery and is likely out until 2025).

The Twins farm system is impressive, boasting top prospects like Brooks Lee and Walker Jenkins, but they won't be impactful members of the ballclub for a few years. If the Twins flip Gray now and further bolster that op prospect pool, it could set the team on a timeline where its best ball is played with guys like Lee, Jenkins, and Emmanuel Rodriguez are all in the Majors.

Add to that how much further along in their development guys like Royce Lewis, Eduardo Julien, Joe Ryan, Bailey Ober, Matt Wallner, and others will be -- plus team control of Pablo Lopez, Byron Buxton, and Carlos Correa -- and all of a sudden it finally feels like the promise of a bright future will be delivered.

Gray's value has never been higher, and it's rare that the Twins have a trade chip like him at the deadline. Flipping him would be a move for the future but it could be the final piece that sets in motion materialization of the team we've been waiting decades for.

No, the Twins should not trade

While it's likely the Twins can get a sweet return package for Gray that perhaps undoes some sins of deadlines past, it's hard to imagine the team being better after the trade.

We all know how easy it is to win the AL Central, but trading a guy who has been your best starter feels like waving the white flag. If not signaling that the Twins don't value winning the division this year, it would make them completely unserious contenders in October.

Let's consider the position the Twins are in with Gray. He's in the last year of his contract and possibly his career, so only contending teams would want to acquire him. Any contender that trades for Gray would do so believing he's another piece of a championship puzzle, but if the Twins are contenders wouldn't they also be in that boat of wanting a starter like Gray?

The only difference is Minnesota is driving the boat; the Twins already have Gray and therefore have a valuable piece of a championship puzzle. Looking at it that way, it's nearly impossible to interpret trading Gray as anything other than giving up on the season.

Maybe the Twins still get into the postseason and win the division, but the message will be more that it's a cool coincidence rather than a serious attempt to compete for a World Series. It won't be validating that they still managed to make the playoffs even after trading Gray, it will be frustration that they don't have a guy like him to help them when it counts the most.

feed

Next