Minnesota Twins: Ranking the 5 Greatest Managers in Franchise History
The Minnesota Twins and Washington Senators have a history of some pretty consistent managers. We rank the five best.
Over 120 combined years of the Minnesota Twins and Washington Senators, thirty-one men have managed the team. Yesterday, we took a look at the five worst managers in team history. It was a pretty unimpressive list.
Today however, we focus on five managers (plus two honorable mentions) who helped lead the franchise to its periods of greatest success. Similar to yesterday, the manager needs to have managed at least a full season, but the team needs to have been a success during his time in Minnesota (or Washington).
Similar to yesterday as well, there are no managers from before 1922, as those teams and managers weren’t at all successful. Let’s get after it.
Minnesota Twins Honorable Mentions
Billy Martin (1969)
W-L: 97-65 (.599)
Average Finish: 1
Easily the most controversial manager in Twins history, Billy Martin liked to win at all costs. Martin led the Twins to their first division title ever. His winning percentage is the second best among Twins managers and he was liked by most fans.
On the opposite side of that, he angered management often and was far from a player’s manager. His infamous fight against 20-game winner Dave Boswell serves as a perfect example of that. He was a very talented manager, but not a great guy. All this adds up to only an honorable mention.
Joe Cronin (1933-1934)
W-L: 165-139 (.543)
Average Finish: 4
The first player-manager on this list, Joe Cronin led the Washington Senators to their third and final American League Pennant in 1933. The Senators won 99 games before losing in five games in the World Series against the Pirates.
Despite virtually the same roster in 1934, the team fell apart, losing 86 games and Cronin was traded the following season. His tough second season keeps him off the list, but he does deserve a mention for winning an AL Pennant.
Rocco Baldelli (2019-)
W-L: 102-60 (.623)
Average Finish: 1
Seem premature to be putting the Twins first year manager on this list? Think about it. Rocco Baldelli led the Twins to a 102 win season, the best season by a first year manager in team history. In addition, he has the best winning percentage of any Twins manager ever.
Now I’m not saying he’s the next Connie Mack, but the 2019 Manager of the Year has some good players and a bright future ahead of him. Give him a few seasons, and he might just squeeze his way onto this list.
No. 5: Washington Senators’ Walter Johnson (1929-1932)
W-L: 350-264 (.570)
Average Finish: 3.2
After retiring from baseball in 1927, Walter Johnson took over as the Senators’ manager in 1929 and led them to three 90 win seasons from 1930-1932. Known as one of the most gentlemanly players in baseball, he is one of just two managers in franchise history to go more than three seasons without getting ejected.
Johnson’s strong and calm leadership helped the team win and win often. His .570 win percentage is first among managers who were with the team for more than one season. In addition, he is one of just two managers to lead the team to three straight season above 90 wins.
His inability to get the team over the hump to the World Series hurts him here, pushing him down to fifth on this list. Regardless, Johnson was a strong manager before his departure for Cleveland in 1932.
No. 4: Washington Senators’ Bucky Harris (1924-1928, 1935-1942, 1950-1954)
W-L: 1336-1416 (.485)
Average Finish: 4.9
Bucky Harris was the first manager to lead the franchise to a World Series title and two A.L. Pennants. He is also the winningest manager in franchise history. Why then is he ranked third? Simply put: after those first two years, his teams didn’t win more than 85 games.
Harris is the only manager in the franchise to be inducted into the Hall of Fame as a manager rather than a player. Despite this, Harris couldn’t get the team to further success after his initial 1924 and 1925 seasons.
His average finish in the AL race of 4.9 per per season was simply not good, and the team lost a majority of their games the rest of his tenure. However, he did bring home that first title with Walter Johnson, and that’s good enough for fourth on this list.
No. 3: Minnesota Twins’ Sam Mele (1961-1967)
W-L: 524-436 (.546)
Average Finish: 3.2
Sam Mele was the second Minnesota Twins manager after taking over for Cookie Lavagetto in 1961, and he finished with the fifth-most wins and the fourth-best win percentage in team history.
Mele was one of only two managers to guide the Twins to an AL Pennant, completing the feat in 1965, The question always was: how much of the team’s success was because of Mele, and how much was because of the team’s stellar core of Harmon Killebrew, Jim Kaat, and more?
In addition, Mele was also dogged by questions over if/when he would be replaced by his third base coach, Billy Martin. Despite all of this, Mele did a strong job managing the team, helping him land in third on this list.
No. 2: Minnesota Twins’ Ron Gardenhire (2002-2014)
W-L: 1068-1039 (.546)
Average Finish: 2.5
Ron “Gardy” Gardenhire managed the Twins for thirteen seasons, putting together one of longest runs of success in the franchise’s history. No manager helped the franchise win more division titles than Gardy’s six division wins.
Gardenhire had the massive bonus of Torii Hunter, Johan Santana, Justin Morneau, and of course, Joe Mauer, throughout some of their best years. This helped Gardy do a lot of winning, but Gardy wasn’t a bad manager in his own right.
His last four years of struggles and lack of postseason success have tarnished his record with the team, but there should be no doubt. Ron Gardenhire is the second best manager in team history, and his record proves that.
No. 1: Minnesota Twins’ Tom Kelly (1986-2001)
W-L: 1140-1244 (.478)
Average Finish: 3.8
The Tom Kelly Twins lost 100 games more than they won. They finished, on average, worse than third place. Doesn’t. Matter. At. All. Tom Kelly is without question, the greatest manager in Minnesota Twins history.
Kelly took over as manager in 1986 and immediately the next year, led the team to their first World Series Championship in Minnesota. Kelly took a group of underdogs and led them to an AL Pennant before expertly managing one of the most dramatic series of all time.
That alone, would have been enough to put him on top of this list, but in addition to that, they won it all just four years later, as Kelly’s decision to leave Jack Morris in Game 7 proved vital to that 1991 title. The Twins may have struggled after that, but that wasn’t Kelly’s fault, as injuries and other issues got in the way of Kelly doing his job.
None of that should take away from Kelly, as he is the undisputed greatest manager in team history. That’s the reason why TK is the only manager to have his number retired by the team and why he will hold onto this spot for a very long time.