Minnesota Twins: 5 best outfields in team history
The 2017 Minnesota Twins had a very good outfield as the team found playoff baseball again. How does that group rank all-time with other Twins outfields?
The Minnesota Twins have built a history that is filled with plenty of success, headlined by World Series victories in 1987 and 1991. Of course, there are plenty of seasons we would like to forget as well. Here is the start of a series that will look at something that should be fun to remember. It will examine some of the best position groups through Twins history. The first position group up in the series is the outfield.
This ends up being an especially exciting adventure with the Twins 2017 instalment of the outfield receiving a lot of credit for the Twins playoff success. It is a group if it stays together could very well find themselves on a similar list to this one in the future.
The group was led by Byron Buxton and his defense in center field. Buxton ended the season at the top of the league in terms of defensive WAR among outfielders. He also found himself second among all position players, only behind Los Angeles shortstop Andrelton Simmons. Offensively, Buxton ended the season with a slash line of .253/.314/.413, 16 home runs, and 29 stolen bases bringing his season WAR to 5.1. The hope is that Buxton has truly found his groove at the plate and will be able to replicate his second half line of .300/.347/.546 which would look very good over a full season.
To Buxton’s right was Eddie Rosario who had a breakout season of his own. Coming into 2017, Rosario was known as a free-swinging, undisciplined hitter. Some adjustments were made and Rosario went on to hit .290/.328/.507 with 27 home runs. Questions surround whether or not Rosario can sustain that type of production, but he sure looked good doing it in 2017 finishing with a 1.7 WAR.
The regular right fielder was Max Kepler. Kepler had a bit of a rough season in comparison to what we expected from him in 2017 as the lefty looked poised for some major growth in his game. Instead, he struggled at the plate against left-handed hurlers making it easier for opposing teams to neutralize his bat, especially late in games. Toward the end of 2017, Kepler seemed to be figuring those lefty-lefty matchups out and finished the season with a slash line of .243/.312/.425, 19 home runs, and a 2.1 WAR.
Buxton, Rosario, and Kepler have provided fans with a young, talented outfield to cheer for and an outfield unit, if it stays together, that could produce some brilliant things. As you can already see, WAR has been referenced several times and that will be one of the major measures used in determining the best outfields in Twins history for the purposes of this list. It will not be the only measure as some other factors will come into play as well. Without any other delay let’s start looking at the top 5 outfields in Twins history.
No. 5- 2012 Twins Outfield
Ben Revere, Josh Willingham, and Denard Span
The 2012 Minnesota Twins by no means had a successful season finishing last in the AL Central with a record of 66-96. A lot of that is chalked up to a starting pitching staff that was not very good and had Scott Diamond lead the team in innings pitched 173 innings with the next closest pitcher logging 100 innings. The outfield did turn in a good season with a total WAR of 10.8.
Denard Span anchored the outfield defense for the Twins in center field. He had a 5.0 WAR and batted .283/.342/.395 and 38 doubles. Span had one of his best seasons as a defensive player with a dWAR of 2.4. I personally have always thought Span also brought great value to teams as a patient leadoff hitter.
After Michael Cuddyer was allowed to leave the Twins, Josh Willingham was signed to fill his spot as the right-handed power bat in the lineup. The Twins signed Willingham to the richest contract the Twins had given to a free agent at the time. Willingham went on to slash .260/.366/.534 and logged 30 doubles, 35 home runs, and 110 RBIs which led to Willingham winning a Silver Slugger award.
Ben Revere rounded out the trio of outfielders in 2012 as he hit .294/.333/.342 while stealing 40 bases. Revere in the 2012 season also turned in his best defensive season according to his defensive WAR of 0.5. Revere was always an interesting player as he had speed and the ability to catch just about anything while often hitting for a good average, but Revere had questionable arm strength and nothing in the way of power at the plate.
No. 4–1976 Twins Outfield
Larry Hisle, Lyman Bostock, Dan Ford, and Steve Braun
The 1976 Minnesota Twins went 85-77 finishing third in the American League West. In today’s game of baseball their 5th best AL record would have meant a playoff appearance but in 1976 it didn’t mean much of anything. When taking into the account the top three WAR totals of this group, the 1976 Twins outfield accounted for an 11 WAR. It is one of the few groups that had four outfielders end the season with a WAR above 2.0.
Larry Hisle led the way with a 4.3 WAR as the primary left fielder. In his fourth season with the Twins after being traded to Minnesota from the St. Louis Cardinals, Hisle hit .272/.335/.394 and 14 home runs and 31 stolen bases. As can be seen in the tweet above, HIsle also hit for the cycle in a game against the Baltimore Orioles on June 4, 1976.
Lyman Bostock was the primary center fielder for the 1976 Twins and finished with a slash line of .323/.364/.430 with 21 doubles and 9 triples and 3.6 WAR. It would turn out to be his last season with the Twins after being the teams 1972 26th round draft pick. Bostock would be granted free agency and sign with the California Angels for the 1977 season.
Right fielder Dan Ford hit .267/.323/.457 with 20 home runs which were good for a WAR of 2.9. “Disco Dan” was in his third season of major league baseball after being drafted by the Oakland Athletics in 1970. While Ford qualifies as the regular right fielder for the Twins, utility player Steve Braun had a better WAR at 3.1 as he hit .288/.384/.353.
The 1977 outfield received a little more attention from places outside of Minnesota than the 1976 outfield here at number four. Hisle and Bostock both garnered MVP votes in seasons where both finished with a WAR over 5. Disco Dan’s numbers were down and Braun was not around as a potent fourth outfield option. That gives the nod to the 1976 crew of outfielders for number four on this list.
No. 3 — 2002 Twins Outfield
Bobby Kielty, Torii Hunter, Jacque Jones, and Dustan Mohr
After 2001 when the Twins saw competitive baseball again after years of cellar dwelling, 2002 saw that continue as the Twins went 94-67 to take first place in the American League Central. The Twins went on to win their American League Division Series matchup over the Oakland Athletics. In advancing to the American League Championship the Twins met the Anaheim Angels but lost the series 3-1 as a part of Francisco Rodriguez‘s breakout party.
Torii Hunter is the name that jumps off the page out of this trio. Hunter batted .289/.334/.524 with 29 home runs and 23 stolen bases in 2002 for a 3.5 WAR. Those numbers helped Hunter earn his first All-Star appearance, a sixth-place finish in MVP voting, and earned his second of nine career Gold Gloves.
While Hunter had a solid season, he was outdone by left fielder Jacque Jones. In 2002, Jones had a career year as he hit .300/.341/.511 with 27 home runs and his career high 5.4 WAR. Along with his best offensive season, he also turned in his best season in the field according to his defensive WAR of 1.0.
Bobby Kielty played the role of utility outfielder for the 2002 Twins. As he rotated defensively, he remained solid at the plate as he batted .291/.405/.484 and added 12 home runs and 14 doubles to his stat line resulting in a 2.7 WAR. Kielty gained attention around the league and finished 4th in Rookie of the Year voting. Another rookie, Dustan Mohr, ended with a WAR above 2 at 2.2. His batting numbers of .269/325/.433 and 12 home runs also got him enough attention in Rookie of the Year voting to finish 8th.
No. 2- 1992 Twins Outfield
Kirby Puckett, Shane Mack, and Pedro Munoz
It feels somewhat weird to place this outfield #2 on this list over the World Series winning outfield of 1991, but the 1992 outfield turned in a better season than the championship outfield of 1991. As a team, the 1992 team followed up the 1991 success by going 90-72 and finishing 2nd in the American League West.
Kirby Puckett continued to be the Twins best player as the team’s center field. Over the 1992 season, Puckett compiled a WAR of 7.1, the fourth-best WAR by a Twins outfielder in team history. That WAR was just a little shy of his career and franchise-best 7.7 WAR. Puckett also led the league in hits (for the fourth time in his career) with 210 while slashing .329/.374/.490 with 19 home runs. Puckett finished second in MVP voting (losing to Dennis Eckersley) while also making the All-Star game, winning a Gold Glove, and Silver Slugger award.
Left fielder Shane Mack found his stride when he arrived with the Twins and he continued to perform well during the 1992 season. Mack slashed .315/.394/.467 and hit 16 home runs and stole 26 bases. In the world of weird stats, Mack led the league in 1992 in the stat of HBP or being hit by the pitch. That season also proved to be the former Rule-5 draft picks’ best season according to his WAR of 6.5, the 9th best WAR in Twins history.
The third outfielder of this trio, Pedro Munoz, also turned in a career-best WAR of 1.4. It also happens to be the lowest WAR of any outfielder on this list, but with Puckett and Mack, it didn’t take much to bump this trio up the list. Munoz slashed .270/.298/.409 and hit 12 home runs.
No. 1- 1964 Twins Outfield
Bob Allison, Harmon Killebrew, Jimmie Hall, and Tony Oliva
The top of this list should include 1963, 1964, and 1965 versions of the Twins outfield. That would make for a somewhat boring list, so instead the 1964 version of the outfield will claim the top spot, but those others shouldn’t go unmentioned and forgotten in any way! The 1964 Twins went 79-83 finishing 6th in the American League, which doesn’t mean a whole lot but the outfield was phenomenal.
Tony Oliva held down right field and had the 6th best season according to WAR by any Twins outfielder with a 6.8 WAR. He hit .323/.359/.557 with 32 home runs and 43 doubles. Oliva’s performance resulted in his first of eight All-Star appearances, a fourth-place finish in MVP voting, and was the winner of Rookie of the Year.
Bob Allison was primarily the Twins first baseman in 1964 but played in the outfield in 61 games that season (and shows off some leather in the video above). He turned in a season-long WAR that places him 12th best among Twins outfielders. He slashed .287/.404/.553 and added 32 home runs. Allison was awarded an All-Star appearance for his performance and even gained some MVP attention.
More from Minnesota Twins News
- Minnesota Twins: Grading the Twins’ Joey Gallo signing
- Minnesota Twins: Grading the Christian Vazquez Signing
- Minnesota Twins: Twins jump into Top 5 in first MLB Draft Lottery
- Minnesota Twins: Byron Buxton wins 2022 Bob Feller Act of Valor Award
- Minnesota Twins: A Twins Homage to the Turkey of the Year Award
These words feel strange to utter, but Twins legend Harmon Killebrew was the third best outfielder in this 1964 Twins outfield. As the third best outfielder, he turned in the 40th best WAR (4.7) by an outfielder in Twins history. On his way to that place Killebrew hit .270/.377/548 and added a league-leading 49 home runs. Killebrew also made the All-Star game and finished 10th in MVP voting.
Center fielder Jimmie Hall rounds out this group with a 4.0 WAR. Hall hit .282/.338/.480 and added 25 home runs and 20 doubles. At age 26 Hall was also able to earn his first All-Star appearance. In case you haven’t been keeping track, that means all four players had a WAR of 4.0 or higher, 3 of the 4 got MVP votes, the league home run champion and rookie of the year were also thrown in there for good measure.
Next: Twins prospects to watch in 2018
There are the top five outfield units in Twins history. Is there a unit you would put on this list?