Hardy v. Gomez Through The Eyes Of The Trade Value Calculator

We took a quick look at the Hardy for Gomez trade a couple days ago, so now we’re going to peer a little deeper with the trade value calculator. Mainly because I wanna bust that thing out again.

Let’s start with Hardy. Hardy had a rough year last year with the bat, but a lot of that was BABIP related. It was just .264 last year, and his peripheral numbers weren’t really any different, although his strikeout rate did climb a bit. Projections have Hardy at around a .330 wOBA, and if we use his career UZR/150 plus his estimated playing time (really I have no idea. I’m assuming the Twins will want to play him as much as possible, and he did get a lot of playing time the past two years, so I’m going with a little over 600 PA) we get a 3.8 WAR for Hardy. Hardy made $4.65 million last year, so bumping him up a bit for arbitration, I really think he’ll only make about 5 million, but just to be pessimistic I’m going to put him at 6 million.


Based on these numbers, Hardy is set to be worth roughly 20 million in surplus value, not including compensation picks after he becomes a free agent. If he rebounds, it is entirely possible he could be a type B or hell even a type A free agent, but to me it’s safer to just estimate his value before picks. Let’s do the same with Gomez, shall we?

Gomez is probably going to be around a .290 wOBA player, and if we project him roughly in the middle defensively of his last to years, and if we give him starter’s playing time, we get a little over 1 WAR for next year. For the three years after that that he will still be under Milwaukee control, I’m going to bump him up gradually, eventually settling on 2 WAR.


Going on the numbers, it looks like the Twins came out ahead. However, if Gomez improves like he has the potential to, this will turn into a win for the Brewers due to the additional years he is under team control. This really seems like your classic win-win for both teams, although losing Gomez’s outfield defense will sure hurt for the Twins.

Want more from Puckett's Pond?  
Subscribe to FanSided Daily for your morning fix. Enter your email and stay in the know.

TEAMFeed More Twins news from the Fansided Network

Hot on the Web From golf.com