Twins Trade Gomez For JJ Hardy


The Orlando Cabrera era in Minnesota is likely over. According to Tyler Barnes of brewers.com’s Twitter, the Twins have traded Carlos Gomez to Milwaukee for JJ Hardy. Gomez had just a .277 wOBA while Hardy had a .292 mark. However, Hardy is at .325 for his career, making him pretty close to average, while Gomez is much worse. Gomez’s peripherals have gotten better every year of his career (better bb/k, better O-Swing), and he is a stud in centerfield. In 2008 he was the best centerfielder in baseball.

However, he seems to have fallen out of favor with Ron Gardenhire with the emergence of Denard Span and for some reason the need to play Delmon Young in left field. Hardy, meanwhile, got sent down to AAA to avoid accumulating more service time. However, Hardy was the 3rd best player from 2007-09 in UZR, making him an extremely valuable commodity.

On the surface, this seems like a rearrangement. The Twins are plugging a hole at shortstop and creating one in the outfield. The Twins outfield had UZR/150′s of epically bad proportions last year (shown here at the position they’ll fill next year)

Delmon Young: -25.6

Denard Span: -3.3

Michael Cuddyer: -22.1

Yeah, I can’t wait to go to war with that outfield. With Kevin Slowey, Scott Baker, Glen Perkins and Francisco Liriano all being fly ball pitchers expect to see Twins outfielders not getting to a  lot of balls next season. Hardy was definitely the right guy to go get, as he and Punto will be probably the best defensive up the middle combo in baseball next year, but I don’t think they gave up the right guy to get him.

Next Twins Game View full schedule »
Tuesday, Sep 22 Sep7:10Chicago White SoxBuy Tickets

Tags: Carlos Gomez JJ Hardy

  • Pingback: November 6, 2009: | FanSided

  • http://www.wavesofarms.wordpress.com johnf34

    i can never log in to your site anymore it always screws up and i cant comment.. so here goes

    you are right in this is a you have to give up something to get something trade. while the twins OF defense will suffer some it really should stabilize the middle infield. gomez is valuable with the brewers because of the nl st…yle. they wouldn’t have taken young. he is awful.

    so by creating a little more of a hole in the OF (where their top prospects play) the twins should have filled a hole totally at SS. im just glad i dont have to see gomez out there catching everything anymore. but i will miss how easy of an out he was. you got an everyday player and did not give up an everyday player. im going with the twins winning this one

  • Pingback: Crown Gems: | Kings of Kauffman | A Kansas City Royals Blog

  • Fetch

    John – I agree they wouldn’t have taken Young. The Brewers priority was to fill the hole Mike Cameron is leaving. I think we gave up an everyday player to get one. Gomez’s peripherals had gotten better and I think will continue to get better.

    Hopefully Jason Pridie can hit a bit so he can play some centerfield before Hicks, Tosoni or Revere is ready.